Wednesday, August 28, 2013

Tolerance in Global Consciousness

I was thinking about tolerance and what that really means. To me, tolerance doesn't have an active connotation but more of a feeling passive acceptance. I think to be truly globally conscious, one must not only tolerate or accept but make the effort to understand. For example,  tolerating a neighbor who practices another religion is all well and good but perhaps having a dialogue or participating in some of your neighbor's ceremonies, rituals or traditions would not only close the gap on our differences but educate in a fuller sense of the word. 

I am interested in Dr. Reimer's references to The Enlightenment and bringing those philosophies to what is happening today. I also believe that global consciousness begins in our back yards. Most people do not have the economic privilege of traveling internationally but can always find some level of diversity close to home. Obviously many of our students are blessed with that privilege but others are not. We should not reserve the experience to connect with others for those occasions.

Susan Arruda

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

Global challenges demand new focus on certain skills

I was struck by this phrase from Howard Gardner in the intro to the "Preparing Our Youth" article:

What is needed more than ever is a laser-like focus on the kinds of human beings that we are raising...  if we are to have a globe worth inhabiting, we must attend unflinchingly to the kinds of human beings that will inhabit it, and the ways in which they deal with one another under often trying circumstances.

I think we've always been concerned with ensuring students have good critical thinking and problem-solving skills, but now we need to add something more to that basic mission.... we need graduates who have empathy for the world's global challenges. This is a tall order, but I think the stakes are too high to ignore this need. From global climate change to the growing socio-economic divide and political polarization, I feel like it is incumbent upon us to consider our role in preparing our students to face, and overcome, these challenges. I don't think we can leave it to a small piece of our social studies curriculum, I think we need to address it in a much more comprehensive way. It seems to me that the citizens and leaders of tomorrow will need special skills and competencies to take on these challenges. Empathy, collaboration, critical thinking,  entrepreneurial thinking, and grit all come to mind. Others have made a similar point below. How do we gather our energy on this topic, and where do we go from here, moving this into the realm of action?

~ Demetri

Global Competency - Fancy Name, Basic Idea

So in sitting down to read through a few more blog posts to get ready for today, I realized that my own contribution was missing!  I wrote this quite some time ago, but clearly forgot to post it – my sincerest apologies.

 

--------------

 

The very first and most lasting point that stuck out to me from our readings came rather early on in Howard Gardner's preface of Educating for Global Competence.  It reads,  "we must be willing to confront examples of bad work and bad citizenship, whether they occur among 20-year-olds or 60-year-olds, in history, literature, and our hometown; and we must help young people develop their own ethical compasses, which they can and should use in conjunction with their mentors and peers."  I think this quote really gets at one of my own core beliefs about living "globally."  In the end, it's really about being that good citizen – demonstrating respect for others and acting ethically.  It also speaks to the idea that this isn't something for older students; all students can begin to engage in the idea that there are other perspectives out there and there are was to communicate and learn with/from others, regardless of where they are currently or where they are from.

 

Another point which stood out to me, this time from the Reimers work (page 191), is this:

 

            These values include compassion and caring, concern for others,

            respect and reciprocity; commitment to universal human rights

            and international covenants (including the expansion of human

            freedoms and capabilities, and recognition of the basic equality

            of all people); and commitment to protecting the environment and

            of addressing global challenges collaboratively.

 

I can't quite think of anything better that we should be teaching our students.  I'm looking forward to making use of the resources Reimers speaks of and exploring these ideas further with my fourth graders this year.


Laura M. (LS)

Monday, August 26, 2013

NAIS Challenge 20/20

Reading about global challenges, I couldn't help but think about two projects I have come across in the past, and I don't know if they are being utilized anywhere at BB&N:

1) the NAIS Challenge 20/20

2) Global Nomads Group (http://gng.org/)

 

From the NAIS Challenge 20/20 website:

Challenge 20/20 is an Internet-based program that pairs classes at any grade level (K-12) from schools in the U.S. with their counterpart classes in schools in other countries; together, the teams (of two or three schools) find local solutions to one of 20 global problems. 

Below are the 20 global problems outlined in High Noon: 20 Global Problems, 20 Years to Solve Them by Jean Francois Rischard. Schools participating in NAIS's Challenge 20/20 program may choose from among these problems. The Challenge 20/20 teams -- who are school groups in the U.S. partnered with school groups in other countries -- work to find local solutions to the global problem.

Sharing our planet: Issues involving the global community

  • Global warming
  • Biodiversity and ecosystem losses
  • Fisheries depletion
  • Deforestation
  • Water deficits
  • Maritime safety and pollution

Sharing our humanity: Issues requiring a global commitment

  • Massive step-up in the fight against poverty
  • Peacekeeping, conflict prevention, combating terrorism
  • Education for all
  • Global infectious diseases
  • Digital divide
  • Natural disaster prevention and mitigation

Sharing our rule book: Issues needing a global regulatory approach

  • Reinventing taxation for the twenty-first century
  • Biotechnology rules
  • Global financial architecture
  • Illegal drugs
  • Trade, investment, and competition rules
  • Intellectual property rights
  • E-commerce rules
  • International labor and migration rules
-Megan Haddadi
LS Technology 

How to be Taught Versus How to Learn

Alan November once wrote, "At an education conference in England an insightful teacher made this distinction between what our schools were designed to do and what we need to do: 'We have succeeded at teaching our students how to be taught and what we need to do is teach them how to learn.'"  While it is a bit simplified, but I think this statement sums up perfectly a change that needs to happen in the world of education in order to help our students prepare for their futures.  This shift in the mindset of educators is one example of the change in skills from the 19th and 20th century world of education to the 21st century skills that both Reimers and the Asia Society require in their definitions of global competency.

Reimers said that "the educational paradox of the beginning of the twenty-first century lies in the disconnect between the superb institutional capacity of schools and their underperformance in preparing students to invent a future that appropriately addresses the global challenges and opportunities shared with their fellow world citizens… Few schools around the world today are equipping students with the skills and habits of mind necessary to collaborate with others, across national boundaries, in inventing and implementing lasting solutions to these challenges…. Preparing students to deal with such complexity and controversies is at the heart of global education. Such preparation is absent today in most schools around the world.  This is paradoxical, because we live at a time of extraordinary institutional capacity."

            The Asia Society similarly stated, "The vast majority of teaching around the world is still geared to preparing young people for lives in the 19th and 20th centuries" and commented on the lack of change to curricula, forms of pedagogy, uses of media, and forms of assessment.  "The world for which we are preparing our youth is qualitatively different from the industrial world in which our public school systems were created."  This need for new skills for the 21st century relates perfectly to Daniel Pink's "conceptual age" that is referenced in the reading and that we read about a year or two ago as a faculty.

            While the skills are undeniably necessary, I couldn't help but notice the need for disposition as well.  I was most struck by Gardner's statement, "What is needed more than ever is a laser-like focus on the kinds of human beings that we are raising and the kids of societies- indeed in a global era, the kind of society- that we are fashioning." 

Reimers summed it up best by stating "Preparing students with the skills and the ethical dispositions to invent a future that enhances human well-being in this space of possibility is the most critical challenge for schools in our time."

 

-Megan Haddadi

Lower School Technology

Local Competency

Can't help thinking that we're not doing enough as a community on teaching and talking regularly about our own environmental stewardship, ethics, integrity, empathy, and human rights. Peter Cohen, NY Businessman referenced in Reimer, spoke of developing trust among societies. Howard Gardner alluded to leading by example, and "helping young people develop their own ethical compasses." 

Are we doing enough to teach to our students' hearts and spirits or just their highly capable intellects?

Joseph Horning

US Music


Summer reading musings

As many of you, I too found the readings interesting. Particularly, because I had a chance to visit an elementary school during my visit to Mexico (school started last week!). As I spoke to teachers and compared notes on teaching, kids, and the role that education plays in the formation of society and other things, many of the conclusions we came to were echoed by the readings. Many of the skills Reimer proposes as necessary, are skills that many caring and engaged teachers are thinking about not just in the USA but other places as well. What was obvious to me during my visit, was that while individual teachers are willing and interested in exposing their students to experiences that can widen horizons and lead to the acquisition of the "affective, action, and academic dimensions" of global competencies, resources can severely limit what a teacher is able to accomplish. 

I agree that it is important that our students become more empathic, interested in and invested in the world around them. The fact is that many of our kids have had the chance to travel and experience other cultures and countries. Many have been exposed to other ways of doing things, languages and have had opportunities to be immersed in other cultures. All of those experiences are valuable in creating an interest and engagement in the world. But, if we are interested in helping them understand some of the world's problems, I would like to make sure that they are exposed to other kids that are not in the same socio-economic status both locally and internationally. Exposing the kids to similarly positioned students (economically speaking) even across different countries via technologies like Skype and video conferencing, is fun and can be a learning experience, but ignores the wide situation that most of the world faces today - poverty. I think that my questions after reading Reimer's proposals for global competencies, are...

How do we promote global competencies globally, particularly if there are limited resources around the world?

For example, last year, during the first grade study of Mexico, the first graders at BB&N held a Skype session with the school in Mexico that I paid a visit to this summer. Kids prepared questions, and were excited to learn first hand from their counterparts how they viewed their daily life. One of the "difficulties" we had when corresponding, and establishing a relationship with this other school was their limited technology. While they could see us, we could never see them because of the internet connection that was provided was from the state did not allow video streaming. This actually prompted the kids to ask even more questions and sparked a desire and curiosity to know more about the kids in that school. My hope is that we continue this relationship with the school, can evoke curiosity, empathy and passion for a place we can't even see, and provoke action from our students to help their new found "amigos."

I look forward to seeing everyone tomorrow!
Maria Elena Derrien
LS Science

Summer Reading

Global Competence seems like a wonderful idea, although quite an overwhelming task for schools to undertake. This is especially true at BBN as we have high academic standards, jam packed schedules full of extra curricula activities and not enough hours in the day to fit it all in.  If we begin to teach Global Competency we may need to start by redefining what Education is..... what do we want and need our students to learn and accomplish in school? Teachers could begin using similar objectives as Global Competency, but on a smaller scale. It is imperative that our students are able to master the essential components that Global Competency aims for at the school-based level first. They need to "learn to recognize perspectives...." and "communicate ideas effectively with diverse audiences..." right in their own classrooms before they are able to generalize this skill and make global connections.  I think BBN as a whole has already begun this process and is moving in the right direction. 
~Cara (MS)

Think Global, Act Local

As someone who has lived for half his life in two different countries and has family members living in four countries, I am very heartened to know that educational institutions are looking to foster global citizens. However I have seen policies implemented in schools that do nothing more than pay lip-service to the concept. I also believe that many are quick to integrate international examples and problems into their curriculum in order to check the global education box.

The conclusion of The Asia Society stated that, "globally competent students are able to do the following:

1. Investigate the world beyond their immediate environment, framing significant problems and conducting well-crafted and age-appropriate research.

2. recognize perspectives, others' and their own, articulating and explaining such perspectives thoughtfully and respectfully.

3. Communicate ideas effectively with diverse audiences, bridging geographic, linguistic, ideological, and cultural barriers.

4. Take action to improve conditions, viewing themselves as players in the world and participating reflectively."

I agree with this almost entirely, however I believe that we need to begin by ignoring the first point. It is my opinion that teaching systems thinking is more fundamental than teaching kids to think about global issues. I believe that in the lower age-levels of education, by focussing on systems thinking we build a stronger foundation on which our students can be successful in a larger range of professions. It is hard for a young person to be able to relate to conditions far beyond their own experiences, so by jumping to such different systems as foreign or global issues one compounds the task beyond their capabilities. By first focussing on a system that more closely aligns with their own knowledge of the world, students can then begin to grapple with the bigger picture issue and thus feel empowered and able to solve problems. As the student ages and begins to be able to grapple more variations on their own life experience, then this is the time to introduce global problems.

I very much hope that one day, students that we teach will help bring peace to the Middle East, eradicate Malaria and save the polar bears. However I believe we teach them to do that by first exploring ways we can reduce the number of school-wide absences due to the cold and flu and creating a carbon-neutral campus, as just a few examples. These examples are then able to be scaled up to national problems such as America's homeless rates, the widening economic gap, and issues surrounding voting rights. I think exposing students to different cultures and world views is essential, and I think there are many wonderful programs around the school that work with different countries and cultures. But as a teacher designing curriculum I think it would be much easier to do so successfully if instead of jumping to foreign problems I focussed on a foundation of systems thinking.

Michael Ewins

Thoughts on summer reading

As I absorbed our various summer readings, I was continually "interrupted" by my musings about how global competency might look in our Lower School classrooms.  I feel that we have been working hard in this direction already, but am looking forward to discussions about how to further this pursuit.

Like Maria, I have just returned (today) from time in Maine.  I, too, had no internet, cell service, TV, or even radio.  Where on earth was she, you might ask?!  Unlike Maria, I was totally content to be unconnected, but I am not feeling very "Globally Competent" at the moment! That status will change quickly.  I have loved reading the posted blogs today and am truly excited for the discussions that are to follow.  As many others commented, I am perplexed by the tension between the acquisition of skills and the time consuming task of helping to develop children with a robust sense of community, respect, and deep caring for difference in all its forms.

See everyone tomorrow, Carter

Global Understanding

As I made my way back from a week-long soccer trip in Scotland with 30-odd BB&N boys, I found this topic to be incredibly relevant, to say the least. Watching our students navigate in unfamiliar territory, some cautious and tentative, others showing the signs of seasoned travel, it was so evident how important global understanding is, and there's no doubt that this need will only increase in time.

At the end of the week, I was so impressed with all of our boys on several levels - thankfully, but not surprisingly, their behavior was one of them!. Firstly, they showed a willingness to try new things and push out of their comfort zones – haggis was ordered on more than one occasion at our meals, as well as other foods unfamiliar to them.  Second was their strong desire to get to know about people from other cultures. We were lucky enough to have receptions planned after a few of our games, and both visitors and hosts eagerly dove in to cross the culture gulf that had been narrowed by their common love of soccer and allowed new friendships to form. Watching them swap Facebook and other social networking addresses illustrated the power and potential that technology will certainly play in these young adults' lives. Lastly, to listen to them speak about their newfound appreciation and affection for another culture demonstrated the power of these kinds of interactions and how strongly they can inform opinions and beliefs.

Given this experience, I came away feeling that we do a very good job preparing our students for a more integrated global future. They are open to new thoughts and perspectives, unafraid to take risks, and capable of synthesizing these things into a modified outlook. Where I feel there's more that we could do is in helping to teach them why this is so important. How do we take learning opportunities such as this and help them see their world as a part of a bigger stage?  I feel that if we can generate better and better results here, we can feel confident that our students are not just globally integrated, but ready to lead globally.

Matt


summer reading

As I enjoy my stay in Glasgow, Scotland I cannot help but think about the importance of "global education". Each day as we drive around this great city we drive on the "wrong side" of the road, and although it feels different for us visitors it is natural for the Scottish folks. Even simple tasks as walking down a flight of stairs-one must travel on the right side of the stairwell- or you might just get a quick yelp from a kind local. Experiencing other cultures, and learning about limits beyond our own lives is clearly important. It was great for the students to learn and start to understand how this foreign city works, thinks and functions. At times in the U.S.A. we tend to think that our methods are the best, however that is not only ignorant, but also simply not true. Over the last week we have experienced how caring, passionate, outgoing and smart the people of Glasgow are-and forever will be.


--
Jesse Sarzana
MS Math/Admissions
Boys' varsity soccer

Think local, global, and sustainable

Both Louisa and Josh (and others) made points I would like to support:  Boston is becoming extraordinarily diverse.  But our overly extended students have little time to step out of activities that in fact insulate them from the "global village" at our doorstep.  Many of our students come to school, then to sports or music lessons or afternoon activities or leagues, then back home (many of them) to  communities with little diversity.  (Community Service projects have done a great job extending these normal routines for some of our kids.)  When I have asked students to take on a documentary project, exploring the theme "A Different Life", many strain to think of anyone whose life is much different from their own or their family's.  Inspired by these articles, I would like to try again to link my students with agencies or immigrant organizations or cultural centers that might welcome young photographers who would like to both interview and to photograph individuals or families who are new to the USA and living here in Boston.  (Colleagues: please send me ideas for this, if you have any.)  The crunch as always will be time:  how can I get students to meet these folks, with time for respectful interviewing and photographing?  Sending them on their own on weekends is hopeless for most of my students.  So--finding another way during the school week is the dream.

Another thought: I appreciated the links Reimers made between global, ethical, and environmental awareness.  When we discussed the Mission Statement from the committee thinking about sustainability last year at the Upper School, it struck many of us that Sustainability should be fully woven together with our academic mission in a global age. 

Parrish
Photography US

--
Parrish Dobson
Art Department--Photography
Buckingham Browne and Nichols School
80 Gerry's Landing Road
Cambridge, MA 02478
617-800-2291

Summer Reading Reflection

The concept of globalization in one's curriculum seems to, in many ways, be self-explanatory and almost implied in our responsibilities as teachers.  However, the inflexibility of curriculum and methods that are noted in this article are very real. While reading this excerpt from what seems to be a valuable reminder of what our purpose is for educating, I couldn't help but reflect on my own curriculum and wonder if it is as diverse and global as it should be.  As an English teacher, I have the wonderful opportunity to expose students to characters, ways of life, and cultures that they can then try to relate to and understand through their writing. This can be very limited, or extremely global, depending on the choice of materials. When I first starting teaching, I attended a NYAIS diversity conference and I was instructed by the keynote speaker to go back to my classroom and merely look at the books that I keep on my shelves. What is available for my students to pick up and read? Is it global? Is it representative of what our entire world has to offer? Can it be related to contemporary issues and promote rich conversation about necessary change? I feel as though these questions are exactly what this reading is trying to have us teachers reflect upon as we embark on yet another school year. I know after reading this, I am considering new perspectives and new worlds that can be introduced through reading and writing.  After all, if students do not have the opportunity to travel and see how others live, work, prosper, or fail, literature often provides us with that opportunity from the comfort of our own homes. Therefore, an elite private school in Cambridge can be global, if we just give students the opportunities to extend their minds beyond the familiar through cultural fiction, non-fiction, different newspapers (besides our own local ones), articles on global science endeavors, musical feats, and art around the world. This reading was a nice reminder of what it means to have an active and energetic curriculum that changes from year to year and reflects our contemporary issues.
The readings presented some very valid and timely points.  Though I found the Reimer reading to be informative, I also found it to be a bit shortsighted and even elitist at times.  I particularly struggled with statements like "I see no reason to expect cosmopolistism from local communities," (p 193).  This deeply undercuts his argument that a global view is important in all classrooms, not just those of schools or districts in places fortunate enough to have enough resources to be able to look beyond the bare minimum and incorporate such forward ideas as these.  This is also reflected in his statements about the important of global service projects.  I strongly agree - but he present sentiment that reflects that those are avenues for education only open to the most economically viable of us all, though there is arguably a benefit of cultural exchange and opportunity for education to both sides.  I did, however, think he made a strong point in presenting the importance of thinking ahead - business and technology are increasingly global exchanges, and it behooves all of us to think about and educate our students using these global models (ie.  where does that iPhone in your pocket really come from? etc.).  


I found myself a little more in accordance with the Asia Society readings, particularly in the preface.  I thought Howard Gardner perfectly stated a boiled down version of what all these readings were working towards presenting when he says "What is needed more than ever is a laser-like focus on the kinds of human beings that we are raising and the kinds of societies—indeed, in a global era, the kind of world society—that we are fashioning."

Steph
--
Stephanie Donohue
Buckingham, Browne & Nichols
Upper School Librarian
80 Gerry's Landing Road
Cambridge, MA 02138

Phone: (617) 800-2150
Email: sdonohue@bbns.org

Think Globally Act Locally

I agree with many of the comments (as does Reimers for that matter) that BB&N and other elite institutions are already educating for global competency in many ways.  The questions for me are: Is there more can I do to enhance what I am doing already and/or are there other ways to more efficiently and effectively satisfy all of my students' learning needs?  

Here are some of my own ideas:

iEarn - Reimers mentioned this organization and after exploring the website, I am pretty excited to see what I can do to get my class involved in one of the projects.  Joining iEarn as a school would be would be great for me, and perhaps encourage others to get involved as well.

Local resources - Another thing that I would like to do this year is take advantage of more of our local resources.  The Asia Society document talks about connecting classrooms to local cultural institutions such as museums and local NGOs.  Walking trips to the Harvard Natural History and Peabody Museums for instance are easy, inexpensive trips that have the potential to support a broader global understanding when initiated with that goal in mind.

Urban School - I have also spent quite a bit of time this summer thinking about BB&N and how it stands out among the other local private schools.  In this vein, one thing I would like to explore further is using the fact that we are an urban school as a jumping off point for understanding more about both our local and global environments.  I think in some ways it is just as important to understand the diversity that exists within our local communities as it is to understand global diversity.  Many of the skills that define global competency can be honed here in our own city with the support of local institutions, families, and organizations.  

These are a few of my own thoughts and individual plans, but I am looking forward to hearing from Rebecca and the speakers about what we could or will do school-wide to help make some of these ideas realities in multiple classrooms.

Louisa


--
Sent from Gmail Mobile

Sunday, August 25, 2013

Summer Reading Thoughts

In his conclusion, Reimers makes the point that communities and schools must make time to discuss and determine the purpose of education -- before success in developing globally competent students will become a reality. He states that because we don't think sufficiently about the purpose of education, "schools, teachers, and students spend great effort in ways that are dissociated from the purposes they value." I hope that at the very least, we will spend time (beyond the opening faculty meeting) discussing what we believe the purpose of education to be, and that we share that belief with our families and students.

I look forward to finding meaningful ways for my kindergarten students to begin the path towards global competency. The summer reading has given me several ideas of projects and activities we might explore. I'm also interested in exploring existing resources developed by Oxfam, UNESCO, Bridges to Understanding, World Savvy, etc.  

~ Deanne  




a related story to the summer reading

The story link below seems to relate to growing trends in the media relating to global coverage in the news.

------------------

Why Global Stories Matter

*Copy and paste the entire address below into your web browser:
http://www.onthemedia.org/2013/aug/23/global-stories-matter/

---------------

(c)2013 www.onthemedia.org

Reimers


I don't think that anyone can disagree with the ideas proposed.  But like Bill said, in a culture which likes to measure and assess learning at every level, it is not a curriculum that is easily measured.  I shudder to think what kinds of measurement tools might be devised to assess the students' progress.  Clearly this is a curriculum which has different implications for different levels.  Good teachers have always tried to maintain a wide perspective in their subject areas.  In our own school, foreign language is taught from Grade one on.  Science teachers can make a point of acknowledging the contributions of every culture.  Teachers of literature can introduce works from other cultures.  And Social Studies can examine issues from multiple perspectives.  This sounds to me like a curriculum that runs through everything we do as teachers.  It is as much a state of mind as a curriculum.  We have a great deal to accomplish as teachers.  I worry that, at least on the elementary level,  if we try to take on too much we could miss some of the fundamentals. 

 

Jack DB


--
Jack Denny-Brown
Grade 5 Homeroom
BB&N Lower School
jdennybrown@bbns.org

Summer reading

As one whose educational training and teaching routine revolve around visits to the Ancient World and "dead languages" in a reactive approach which creates teachable scenarios, I find it somewhat daunting to be confronted by a challenge which calls for a more proactive formula with a view to forecasting and predicting potential future educational scenarios.  We are served with a call for a more fully integrated curriculum in the hopes that it will more successfully address the various challenges which skilled and educated individuals will face in the future. I agree with my colleagues who have been quick to observe that we do already address this challenge to a fairly healthy degree.  I am curious to see how the framework for the collective approach will identify itself.

Tony Breen

--
Anthony Breen
Assistant Director, Middle School
Buckingham Browne & Nichols School
80 Sparks Street
Cambridge MA 02138